Molecular Biology and Evolution
9: 836-855.
1992
Rate and mode differences between nuclear and mitochondrial small-subunit rRNA genes in mushrooms
T. D. Bruns & T. M. Szaro
Department of Plant Pathology, University of California, Berkeley
94720.
Abstract
Sequences from homologous regions of the nuclear and mitochondrial
small-subunit rRNA genes from 10 members of the mushroom order
Boletales were used to construct evolutionary trees and to compare
the rates and modes of evolution. Trees constructed independently
for each gene by parsimony and tested by bootstrap analysis have
identical topologies in all statistically significant branches.
Examination of base substitutions revealed that the nuclear gene
is biased toward C-T transitions and that the distribution of
transversions in the mitochondrial gene is strongly effected by an
A-T bias. When only homologous regions of the two genes were
compared, base substitutions per nucleotide were roughly 16-fold
greater in the mitochondrial gene. The difference in the frequency
of length mutations was at least as great but was impossible to
estimate accurately because of their absence in the nuclear gene.
Maximum likelihood was used to show that base-substitution rates
vary dramatically among the branches. A significant part of the
rate inconstancy was caused by an accelerated nuclear rate in one
branch and a retarded mitochondrial rate in a different branch. A
second part of the rate variability involved a consistent
inconstancy: short branches exhibit ratios of mitochondrial to
nuclear divergences of less than 1, while longer branches had
ratios of approximately 4:1-8:1. This pattern suggests a
systematic error in the branch length calculation. The error may
be related to the simplicity of the divergence estimates, which
assumes that all base positions have an equal probability of
change.
Return to Bruns home page.
Return to Szaro home page.
Return to Bruns Lab home page.